Hacker News Reader

Agreed there is no explicitly enumerated right, but in the context of computing, it is not illegal for a computer to transmit “untrue” information. Fraud is a significantly higher bar. I am not a cyber-lawyer.

In the U.S., most rights are not explicitly enumerated. People are assumed to have all conceivable rights, and the restrictions must be explicitly enumerated. There is no law against lying in general.

There is, however, an explicitly enumerated right to freedom of speech. There are only a handful of recognized categories of non-protected speech. Lying isn't one of them.

In American law, the right to speak is assumed. It is the lack of a right to speech that is the exception. There are only a handful of categories of unprotected speech, which can be easily enumerated, and lies aren't one of them.

Fraud, defamation, perjury, and obstruction of justice are illegal. That's a much narrower restriction than a ban on lies.

You cannot keep me from lying. You can only hold me accountable if my lies do harm. So I would take it as a "natural right" even though I realize those are contended.