Hacker News Reader

What does the timing have to do with visibility though? What government move is quick enough for that to matter? Do you really believe that if “the government” wants to look at money flow they won’t do it until FedNow is live? Each transaction is tracked by an ID accessible by people in the system, not sure why you men by “invisible”.

View on HN

As an example, if you're say, Venmo, your ACH batches won't contain information about the individual p2p money movements of your customers.

Venmo doesn’t use ACH when moving from Venmo to Venmo. And is the same with FedNow. If you send money from BankA account to bankB account, that’s an ACH transaction and it’s recorded as such. Same with Fed now.

Right, these concerns are predicated on apps built natively on FedNow gaining market share to rival Venmo enough that these transactions are no longer opaque. If everybody uses it the same way they use ACH, there's no difference to the state of the world today.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com