How I hacked 37signals job board to save $400
grep-i.com
grep-i.com
While searching for contents fits the medicine cupboard analogy, searching for a product is similar to visiting a shop, and browsing stuff till you find something worth buying; you don't know what you're looking for, and a vast array of things might provide the right answer.
The difference between these two searches seems to be a major reason for the current frustration with search engines.
I do not think a one-size-fits-all search engine would be the answer here. :)