Comment by tehnub | Hacker News Reader

Comment by tehnub | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

IMO the ranking goes like this:

1. IMAX 70mm

2. 70mm (non-IMAX, 2.2/1 aspect ratio)

3. Dual Laser IMAX (4K, can show the full 1.43/1 picture instead of just 1.9/1)

4. Single laser IMAX (4K, shows 1.9/1)

5. Dolby Cinema (4K, aspect ratio probably 2.39/1, not sure)

6. 35mm film

7. Non-laser IMAX

8. Regular theater

(1) is the most special, (2) is still quite special as only every few years do these theaters typically bring out 70mm projectors, (3) is also pretty special because rarely do movies return to IMAX where you can see the full uncropped image. (4) and (5) will still have great picture and sound quality compared to almost any home setup (OLED has contrast advantage always). (6) is pretty special, as [0] says: The 35mm prints have been made photochemically, preserving all the rich analog color of the original 65mm photography. (7) will have a big screen and good sound. (8) regular theaters are still good too. The value of the movie-going experience is not insignificant, which you get at any theater.

[0]: https://www.oppenheimermovie.com/tickets/formats/

> The value of the movie-going experience is not insignificant, which you get at any theater.

Not arguing, just curious: what do you perceive the value to be in going to a (8) plain 'ol regular theater? As opposed to something like a 65" OLED in your living room.

I think it's partly the shared event and ritual. You're taking part in something with hundreds of other people, and a lot of effort goes in to making it just right (with a good projectionist and a cinema that gives a shit)

65" OLED is fantastic (better color, contrast, resolution). One thing is that you get to see the movie sooner. May or may not be a big deal. Another is that you get a big screen with few distractions around (hopefully). Something about being in the dark room with the big screen makes the experience more memorable and immersive. You've got your popcorn. You can recreate all that at home to a large extent though. There's also something to the communal aspect -- it's at least a little intriguing to look around and see who else is at the movie. Sometimes it's a great crowd during the showing and there's laughter and applause and gasps, and that adds something to the experience. Sometimes you strike up a conversation with somebody afterward. You also get the experience of intentionally going out. Maybe you meet or bring some friends or family, maybe you get some ice cream afterward (I've also gone to a few movies alone, and that's its own interesting experience). I guess that's mostly all to say it's a little more fun. I also have some notion which is probably a little silly of supporting the thing I'm seeing. This especially applies to movies like Shin Kamen Rider, which I made sure to catch in the one or two days it was playing in the US.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com