This sounds extremely annoying.
My belief is that things like books, music, and other content take time to make and users fully understand that. What Color does, however, is help consumers realize they can reward creators without necessarily spending money, but instead with publicity, arguably even more valuable for new artists/stores/websites.
Your service would need to curate the content and gain enough trust for people already burned to accept the risk.
PS. The styling of the 'Free Download/powered by Color' button is broken on my iPad (The 'Free Download' text is below the actual button).