Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

xianshou

No, this is precisely correct. To simplify further:

1. Start H4 and H7

2. Flip H4 when it runs out (4-minute mark)

3. Flip H7 when it runs out (7-minute mark, 1 minute left on H4)

4. Flip H7 back when H4 runs out again (8-minute mark, 1 minute elapsed on H7)

5. When H7 runs out again (after 1 minute), exactly 9 minutes have passed

View on HN

Your summary is incorrect. Step 3 doesn't match what GPT-4 actually said:

> When the 7-minute hourglass runs out, don't flip it yet, but note that the 4-minute hourglass has now been running for 3 minutes on its second run. (This marks 7 minutes.) When the 4-minute hourglass runs out again, flip the 7-minute hourglass. (This marks 8 minutes.)

Notice that GPT-4 says not to flip H7 when it runs out, which is a mistake.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com