Hacker News Reader

Comment by lynx23 | Hacker News Reader

> scammer presidential candidates who are all antivaxxers

Uhu, borderline hysterical. What are you talking about, actually? Sounds like you have been confused by ongoing political wars...

View on HN

I assume they mean RFK Jr and DeSantis; RFK Jr is a full-blown conspiracy theorist; DeSantis is at least a little anti-vax-y.

I am referring to them, yes. After all, nobody else exists, so there's no one else to refer to really.

Although Marianne Williamson (maybe the distant #3 alternative candidate) is generally antivax since she's from the older group of naturalistic-fallacy hippie women where the idea originally caught on.

RFK and Desantis are doing it because the vaccine was a major policy accomplishment of both the last two presidents, ie the party leaders they're running against. It may seem like a natural political opportunity but it's a bad move since normal voters don't like crazy people.

RFK is doing it because he's thought vaccines were bad for literally his entire adult life, here's an article from 2011 where Salon had to retract a thing they let him publish in 2005 on the subject:

https://www.salon.com/2011/01/16/dangerous_immunity/

You're not required to bring everything you've believed your entire life to your political campaign though. In fact, it's better not to. You're there to do a job, not get a prize for believing things.

I have no side in this debate because I don't support any of the potential candidates, but since US politicians are not effectively disciplined by their base but rather by their donors, it's quite reasonable for the base to seek evidence of past commitment to issues they prioritize. It's a very poor heuristic, but it's all they've got. As you said, the politicians are doing a job, but they don't take their orders from the voters. The system is utterly ruined.

Is this what you call gaslighting? Please don't do it, whatever it is.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com