Hacker News Reader

Comment by gt384u | Hacker News Reader

Something I'd be curious to hear from the pretty lisp designers: what advantages do you feel this offers over an Emacs which just highlights the symbol of interest or region between the matched parens for a particular code block?

By way of context, I was a test subject for a perhaps related project called Code Bubbles http://www.andrewbragdon.com/codebubbles_site.asp a while ago. Since it was for Java, a language which is comparatively verbose and I often have difficulty getting decent code density with, this new IDE interaction was truly novel and I found often useful.

I test drove the Pretty Lisp Demo and felt myself wanting for code density in a language where I don't typically have those issues. It was just too hard to fit a useful quantity of code in a screen.

View on HN

> what advantages do you feel this offers over an Emacs which just highlights the symbol of interest or region between the matched parens for a particular code block?

This already exists: http://www.foldr.org/~michaelw/emacs/mwe-color-box.el

(you can see a screenie in http://www.foldr.org/~michaelw/emacs/color-box.png)

That is extremely shiny. Can I get that in Vim?

Well, this is not quite the same, but you can get indent-level highlighting in vim via these sorts of plugins:

http://www.vim.org/scripts/script.php?script_id=3361

http://www.vim.org/scripts/script.php?script_id=1800

Some screenshots:

http://nathanaelkane.imgur.com/indent_guides

http://viming.blogspot.com/2007/02/indent-level-highlighting...

Of course, you can also get rainbow parenthesis in vim via:

  :let g:lisp_rainbow = 1

There should also be some way to get background highlights based on sexpr's instead of just indent level, but I haven't personally seen it.

Edit: actually, come to think of it, I seem to recall hearing that the slimv[1] plugin can do this. But I haven't really played with it myself.

[1] - http://www.vim.org/scripts/script.php?script_id=2531

Thank you. I knew that it was an editor feature I'd seen before for lisp code, but didn't recall the name of any one in particular.

You're welcome! I don't know how useful it is in practice. I myself don't mind the parens as long as I can see them match.

I... love... this...

Seriously though, I wish that emacs put effort into a more modern rendering architecture. So that you could implement this sort of visualization in a more flexible way.

And here's a small survey of lisp expression highlighting UIs from a few years ago, "Five approaches to s-expression highlighting": http://lemonodor.com/archives/2005/08/five_approaches.html

Hmm, code bubbles actually looks interesting. I might actually try something like that.

Pretty list still doesn't look very appealing to me. It doesn't help organize the code, all it does is replace parenthesis with visual boxes.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com