Ask HN: Commenting System?

2 points30004 comments

What is the best, in your opinion, commenting system for a website. is it like hacker news, is it like twitter, medium or maybe new york times?

threaded, non-threaded?

comments below the fold, to the side like NY times, or maybe in a centered modal like facebook?

View on HN

By far the reddit\hacker news style. I think it's one of the main pillars of reddit's success. I want to be able to reply to, and see replies to, any comment.

thank you!

Depends on the website, depends on their audience. Some people can’t get to grips with threaded comments, for example.

thank you!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com