Hacker News Reader

Comment by ghosty141 | Hacker News Reader

But each has to do a lot of stuff. People on such big servers build farms with hundreds of mobs dropping thousands of items which then go through redstone sorting systems.

View on HN

I wouldn't say "each has to do a lot". There's a few trivial behaviours usually. Especially if you know what behaviours are common, you can optimise entity lists for that.

But that's not even what we're talking about here. This was a short-lived test server with new environment, not huge farms. The super high GC stats we see here are the baseline behaviour. More complex scenarios will push this even more.

The kind of mental gymnastics that people do here to justify needing 8 GB of RAM with a turnover of 3 GB per ~minute~ second to handle 1000 users.

Per second.

It is definitely more than required, but let’s not go to the other end, it is neither a static html page.

> People on such big servers build farms

~Normally, yeah, but Folia is based on Paper which, AFAIK, is known for its unreliability when it comes to the technical aspects of Minecraft (ie redstone and farms.) Even your bog-standard simple item sorter is apparently a bit hit-or-miss on Paper.~

Edit: Possibly outdated info, things sound better re: technical Minecraft support on Paper now according to 'ocelotpotpie.

The hardcore technical folks seem to prefer things that don't alter the vanilla mechanics quite as much as Paper, it's true. But FWIW there are lots of farm and redstone designs that work reliably on Paper.

> But FWIW there are lots of farm and redstone designs that work reliably on Paper.

Ah, good to know - been a long while since I last tried Paper.

Its fine for most stuff the average player does. I wouldnt run a redstone computer on it but I personally never had an issue with my farms.

> Even your bog-standard simple item sorter is apparently a bit hit-or-miss on Paper.~

My simple sorters have been working just fine(tm) on Paper in the last (>5) few years.

I do hear co players having occasional problems with fancier set ups, but most automation just works.

Thousands of items is small. Factorio doesn't need that amount of RAM when it routinely handle dozen of thousands of items every ticks.

Remember Minecraft is written in Java, not C++. The Bedrock version is written C++ but has only experimental, very rough native server software that is almost never used.

> Factorio doesn't need that amount of RAM when it routinely handle dozen of thousands of items every tick.

It might not inefficiently allocate all that RAM every tick, but it still has to scan a lot of RAM, and write to a bunch of locations to update the game state.

It loves CPUs with huge caches because of that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com