Hacker News Reader

Comment by seymon | Hacker News Reader

One thing I find difficult using access control systems as a distributed service like Zanzibar is a convenient and performant way to search and filter resource data using permissions. For example defining database queries that should only return resources a subject has access to based on Zanzibar permissions.

View on HN

At Google, I believe some client applications build and maintain "permission-aware" search indexes based on the permissions in Zanzibar. In essence, Zanzibar can be queried to figure out the object ids a particular subject has access to. These object ids can then be hydrated via a database query or separate service call.

At Warrant, we're experimenting with allowing customers to maintain searchable metadata in Warrant and exposing a "query" API[1] that can automatically hydrate objects based on that metadata.

[1] https://docs.warrant.dev/warrants/query-warrants/

SpiceDB/Authzed has "Lookup"s. There's LookupResources for finding what a user has access to, and LookupSubjects now too to see who has access to a resource. Great capability. https://authzed.com/blog/lookup-subjects

Same reason I didn't invest much in this field yet.

When you access one resource it's fine to a do a roundtrip, but with listing, filtering, searching if you don't join at query time it doesn't work. I'm not entirely sure how they achieve it and I found it annoying that it's never mentioned because it's very common.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com