Hacker News Reader

Comment by rnk | Hacker News Reader

If you didn't meet those people, then either you're ignorant yourself -(with all due respect), or you are not looking closely.

I'm from the south. I went to high school there, I got my college degree from there. I live there from the time I was born until my mid-20s. The south is full of racist, horrible people, it was common in my youth to hear people talk badly about Jewish people, people dropped the n word. I heard people talking about non-Christians shouldn't get to vote. I heard plenty of sexist words about women for men. It just beggars belief that you would never hear this kind of speech.

I just don't commonly hear this on the west coast in the US like I did in my years in the south. And unfortunately I still hear it when I go to visit.

Not everyone is like that! But enough people are that, so that you're going to encounter it over and over again.

View on HN

As someone living in the South, I would really appreciate it if you stopped tarring everyone who lives in a Southern state as a "racist horrible person". There are many millions of people who live in the South.

Some of them are racist, millions of them are not.

> The south is full of racist, horrible people

Amazing these kinds of comments are allowed here. Imagine if someone made a similar comment about any other group other than "the south".

For the record, I am a brown immigrant living on the West coast.

"The south".

Like it's all one thing.

You know, that big geographic area that's much larger than most countries in the world, with a population at least as diverse.

The most racist place I ever lived was about 30 mins from Philadelphia.

Grew up there, and there were literally burning crosses in people's yards and race riots in my high school.

I've lived in "the south" now for almost 20 years and never encountered even a fraction of the racism I saw growing up.

When I was a kid in the south my barber constantly talked about the problems of black people and that he saw crosses being burned and that he didn't want his daughter to like black boys. I'm not making this up! They literally burned crosses in the town I grew up in.

Looks like you found a racist dude in one of the over 128 million people that live in the south.

I'm sure you could find some more if you look.

It's over 38% of the county's population, and by far the most populous region of the U.S. [1].

You can find racism anywhere. Mostly in very small percentages, mostly in uneducated populations, and not restricted to any particular ethnicity.

[1]https://www.census.gov/popclock/data_tables.php?component=gr...

In my very first comment I said that not all people are like that. Yet sadly, to this day, I constantly do meet people making casual racist comments when I go to the south. And when I say the south, I include the state where I was born which is one of the states that fought against the US government in the civil war.

Not all people are like that but there is an issue that a lot of people are like that.

Alabama had a ban on interracial marriage in its state constitution. Struck down in the 60s by SCOTUS but still on the books after that. When they put it to a referendum to repeal it from the text of the law - the vote was surprisingly close:

> The amendment was approved with 59.5% voting yes, a 19 percentage point margin, though 25 of Alabama's 67 counties voted against it.

That was in 2000.

And Oregon didn't repeal its black exclusion laws until 2002.

And just over 20 years before that there were riots in Boston over desegregation of schools.

It's so funny, this romantic notion that many from the north have of how supposedly enlightened they are, while the south is a bunch of backwater hicks. I know, I used to have it too, as did my wife then, who was Canadian. People thought we were crazy when we moved to Texas.

I really had my eyes opened. I encountered far more tolerance in Texas than anything I'd ever experienced up north.

Try being black in some communities in Vermont. See how well you do. Compare it with New Orleans.

Of course you can find racism and racist enclaves anywhere, but this asinine idea that "the south" is some sort of backwater racist hole while the north is a pristine liberal utopia is nonsense.

Also, I hate to disabuse you further, but I should also point out that the population of the capital of Alabama, Montgomery, is 60% black and 30% white. Whites are firmly a minority in the capital.

Atlanta: 50% black, 40% white. New Orleans: 60% black, 30% white.

I could go on, but it's boring. I'm not even listing any of the several large southern cities that are majority Hispanic.

The south has an incredibly diverse population. And sure, it had a dark history of racism (so does the north) but FFS it's not 1860 anymore.

As a Canadian I was tempted to use my own experiences of people spouting stuff that made me think I had fallen in a time warp to the 1950s. But that's subjective. And the above thread was about the southern USA.

I was not trying to pile on the south bashing so much as to simply point out that pockets most people would consider remarkably regressive persist, not specifically in the south per se, as just in North America at all. I was particularly interested in the last bit: 60% majority in favour, yet 25 counties majority against. Localized, varies by community. It's like that in Ontario too.

As someone who's lived all over, the primary difference in the south is that there are large African American populations.

Try being black in South Dakota or Maine.

Racism and othering exists everywhere, but physical proximity and interaction with the class in question moderates it heavily. It's harder to hate someone you know personally: that's why segregationists were such staunch opponents of any social integration.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com