"But imho it's not so much TV that is broken. It's advertising. In today's world of on-demand personalized information, advertising has zero value."
What happens to Google & Facebook without advertising?
What happens to Google & Facebook without advertising?
I'd still rather pay for GMail instead of seeing ads.
You can; it costs $50/year, though: http://www.google.com/apps/intl/en/business/features.html
disclosure: I have no affiliation with Fastmail.fm other than being a longtime customer.
I don't know about you, but I would pay for Gmail in a heartbeat. It's a great service. I can guarantee that Comcast would make something 1,000 times crappier and that I'd waste hundreds of hours of my life fighting with it.
In fact, I'd rather be paying for Gmail so that I'd be their customer and not their product. I'm happy that I pay for Pinboard because I know that it motivates them to please me and not someone else to whom they can sell my data. And I'm happy because my payment is an investment in the continued existence of a service I value.
You're asserting that Gmail and Google search aren't valuable enough for people to pay for them. If that's true, they shouldn't exist in a free market. But I don't think it's true.
> You're asserting that Gmail and Google search aren't valuable enough for people to pay for them. If that's true, they shouldn't exist in a free market.
The free market involves advertising. How much entertainment in paid for with advertising? Should none of that exist? Should, e.g., "How I Met Your Mother" be cancelled? I seriously doubt it would exist in an advertisement-free market.