It just doesn't seem right that what happened here didn't happen somewhere else.
The chances of intelligent life existing outside Earth are lower than the chance of that same intelligent life speaking flawless Swedish. We might as well send some Europop records to space as signals to aliens.
"Intelligence" is a human invention created by humans to describe humanity. It only applies to humans and human-like beings.
Life is likely plentiful in the Universe. Earth-like life is almost certainly unique.
As long as we know of only one occurrence of intelligent life we have no clue of the probability. And human intuition on what's right doesn't help us here.
It's absurd to claim intelligent life doesn't exist, as we know it does on Earth. And it's absurd to claim any level of probability for other intelligent life until we have one more data point.
Don't we have many points for both? There are ~8.7 million species on the planet. What we only have one data point for is a planet that contains life and intelligence.