Hacker News Reader

Comment by yangikan | Hacker News Reader

What are your favorite workout apps?

Honestly Beat Saber burns calories like nobody’s business.

Boxing games are great too. I literally need to pause and rest when I’m playing Thrill of the Fight, but it never feels like a “workout,” just like I’m doing a thing and it’s physically hard.

Heard good things about Fit XR, but I think it’s a subscription, which sucks.

Thrill of the fight is brutal lol, I just take all the time during rounds and still get exhausted by the end.

Thrill of the fight requires lots of space though. Beat Saber and Fit XR (and most other rythym games) can be done in place.

Thrill of the Fight has the highest average calorie burn in VR right now.

I busted my elbow with that one and it never got better.

I thought about getting a boxing game for VR, but I worry about injuring my elbow by punching forward and hitting nothing and having all the momentum get absorbed by the limit of my elbow joint.

Do you just avoid punching directly forward, or do you pull your punches, or what?

It is basically shadow boxing, which requires its own techniques to avoid injury, because ya, no bouncing off of something to stop or even return your energy:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadowboxing

Yep, keep your arms tight and stop your arm and bring it back after a punch. Lots of posts on reddit of shoulder injuries from playing these boxing games without being careful:

https://www.google.com/search?q=reddit+quest+boxing+shoulder...

Can’t really understand why thrill of the fight (which has the best engine of the boxing games) only lets you play against realistic, male characters. It would be tons more fun if you could play against fantasy characters and even politically incorrect ones. Everyone i talked to seemed to agree. Once another studio fills this niche, and provided that their engine is just as good, i think TotF will be sidelined.

Besides what the other person said, I subscribed to Supernatural for a while, and I thought it was doing good things for me, but it just seems like too much money monthly for what they provide. But it could be right for some.

FitXR is only $10/month, and it has been my go to for a few years now. It was even cheaper when they just sold the app without a subscription, I have the option to revert to that as well if I stop buying the subscription (an option not available anymore).

My wife uses Supernatural almost every day, and while it's a bummer to be subscription, she really enjoys the new content that keeps coming in.

I liked it too, but did not think the value was there at $18 a month.

I’m hoping Apple comes through with better packaged with apple fitness.

Les Mills Body Combat is a good non-subscription option.

My wife uses Supernatural almost exclusively, and I use Beat Saber.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com