Hacker News Reader

Together, we can create a web ecosystem that respects users' autonomy

Maybe 20 years ago I would've believed that coming from Google, but no, it's clear they're going full authoritarian to get users under their control like the rest of Big Tech and using the classic "security" argument to do it.

View on HN

It is quizzical, isn't it? "Pervasive tracking of users goes against their autonomy". But what about when you do it? "We need to be able to keep the lights on, don't we? And anyways, users chose to visit our page, so they consented to any tracking" - how does any of that not apply to extensions the user installs?

The cognitive dissonance of being a company that makes all its money spying on users, has a profit motivation to prevent others from spying on users, and needing to pretend to take the moral high ground for PR reasons at the same time.

You are talking about google's hypocrisy, but quizzical actually means mildly amused and not confusing or ironic.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com