Hacker News Reader

Comment by masfuerte | Hacker News Reader

Excel has several UI quirks that date back decades. It's never been consistent with the rest of Office even. If Microsoft changed it the accountants would revolt.

View on HN

> If Microsoft changed it the accountants would revolt.

What's stopping other trades from forming a similarly powerful lobby, like accountants seem to have?

do you have some examples of that quirks?

You can expect data to be destroyed when automatically parsing csv/tsv (default behaviour), especially because it's dependent on the last settings used in the text-to-columns wizard.

Then there's all well-known bugs like floating point addition and locale-dependent function names and 1904 dates.

Conditional formatting accidentally pasting is all over the place.

As others have mentioned, copying and pasting in Excel is bizarre. Highlight the cells to copy; select copy - the source cells now have marching ants around them; perform any action that causes the marching ants to disappear and that content can no longer be pasted. It’s as if those cells are locked as the copy buffer as opposed to some in memory copy like every other copy operation.

It is neither copy nor paste. The copy is "remember this as reference" and paste is "do to this cell to make it relatively similar to the other".

Cut and paste is even better. If the cell to be cut is being referenced, the referencing cell can magically update to the place to paste to.

Selecting and copying the /content/ of a cell is a very normal copy and paste operation.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com