Hacker News Reader

Comment by shtack | Hacker News Reader

“Consistent” UX is often one of the downsides of cross platform frameworks. Android and iOS have distinct UX details that users expect in their apps.

View on HN

Yes but React Native uses native elements. It doesn't fake them like Flutter. It just provides a unified way to address them.

This is a problem even with desktop apps. Look at the print dialog abomination that Firefox unleashed on us.

Chrome did it first, and (at least on Windows) the system print dialog sucks anyway.

Sure, and the single biggest weakness over at Mozilla is that they're more focused on building a better Chrome (a.k.a. following the leader) instead of innovating or fixing bugs. That's why we've lost useful tools like the 3D DOM rendering in favor of a fucking chat client in Thunderbird. Or why if your system is lagged enough you can hit Cmd+T, start typing a URL, hit return, and have Firefox load the new URL in the old tab… but at least we have that awful search instead of separate, proper, URL and search bars. It's why we get limited-time-only!!! paid themes while all extensions get disabled because someone forgot to deal with an expired certificate.

Mozilla, and by extension the Firefox crew, lost sight of their core competencies a long time ago. Every dumbass design decision the Chrome folks make, Mozilla will emulate a few years later.

IIRC Thunderbird is a separate project now, not part of Mozilla, no?

Well they went corporate (MZLA Technologies) but they are still under the mozilla foundation.

I also think Firefox had lost its way, but not because of these things.

Definitely agree on some of this stuff. The themes situation sounded pretty delusional the whole time. And there were many more decisions like that.

However, what is this about separate search and url boxes? I have that, still. You don't have to have just the single box. Still, the main url box still behaves as a search either way. Is that what you mean?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com