Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by throwaway2056 | Hacker News Reader

Full thread

throwaway2056

(I wish github does not become one but sadly gitlab is beset with constant pain)

- no proper communication - unclear future plan - poor documentation

See for example

https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab/-/issues/380872

View on HN

I've looked at your example, but all I'm seeing is a deprecation process for a feature with an alternative workflow, and all sorts of warnings, a timeline and even a shifting timeline to allow users to update.

Can you specify exactly what you find lacking? Is it the fact that there is a breaking change?

I'm not familiar with this case, but from a glance I see proper communication, a clear future plan and adequate documentation. I'm not affiliated with gitlab btw.

If one runs the command until last week or so it exited (with failure) but pointed out that it is deprecated and provided a link to https://docs.gitlab.com/runner/register/index.html

    gitlab-runner register

documentation pages that once again stated the obvious. No difference at all. Then you rerun the command - same bounce out. No clue. The docs linked at the URL still say to use the --registration-token.

finally (after digging into stackexchange and gitlab issue) one needs to run the command without

    --non-interactive

No where in the documentation it (until last week) that this should be removed for registering a runner as of today (last few months).

That's the thing though! They announced one of the most critical part of the runners (the token auth) to be deprecated for months before the replacement was even available for teams to switch to. Very bizarre

I feel like if gitlab were worse it would be less frustrating because my expectations would be considerably lower.

Slow UI, JS is a must, looks bad.

the almost haiku!

Use gogs.

I'm currently looking at alternatives for self-hosting. Do you prefer gogs to gitea? why, if so?

I’ve been using gitea for years and I love it. I heard about gogs after migrating to gitea, but it seems like gitea is mostly an improved gogs.

I prefer projects maintained by single or few developers. Gogs seems to be that kind of project. Gitea is maintained by some kind of community. Other than that, I think they don't differ that much. Gitea is Gogs fork after all.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com