Hacker News Reader

Comment by chaostheory | Hacker News Reader

Yes, having a counterpoint with a relevant data point that you missed is “weak”

you are ignorant, making your argument weak and just plain wrong. Should people no longer point out when comments are really wrong? You’re also over generalizing while being completely incorrect ie making shit up

View on HN

You don't know if he's ignorant based on his one comment, seems you are also over generalizing, also this comment isn't really ignorant. He did state issues that are conceptually accurate and generally describe the situation, regardless of whether the number in the yearly salary is a little different, this doesn't change the problem.

No, he was not accurate. There’s also a large difference between $300k in compensation and $150k. Unionizing will not help with that

You guys are just continuing to help prove my point

You didn't provide a "relevant data point". The base salary for an L3 (rank-and-file) SWE in the Bay Area (which is one of the highest paid areas in the US) is 140K on levels.fyi. You've compared this to the total comp which includes stock (that tanked recently), and a bonus (which isn't guaranteed). You're asserting that you're right and I have no idea what I'm talking about baselessly and being agressive and rude. I don't need to engage with that, nobody does.

In the article if you read it, most of Sundar’s criticized compensation came in the form of stock. Total comp is relevant. It might be down, but it’s still way more than 150k. It’s double or more

L3’s are newbies. They’re one step above interns. It’s easy to become an L4. L4 - L5 are rank and file.

You’re still really wrong and very ignorant on the subject.

As for being aggressive, I’m not the one over generalizing and calling the rank and file at Google spineless

> bonus (which isn't guaranteed)

You're again showing that you're uninformed. The bonus is guaranteed for everyone that doesn't get the lowest level of performance evaluation.

>the lowest level of performance evaluation

The level that's synonymous with "this was your notice that you should start looking elsewhere because you will be let go in 6 months or less".

The bonuses are as guaranteed as your next paycheck.

Stock "tanked" 35% from the top after running up for years. It doesn't make the stock component of the compensation zero. Median compensation is >$300K. You could have made your point without making up numbers that are easily fact checked.

Other guy is right, you're misinformed and continuing to argue when you're wrong makes you ignorant and foolish.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com