Hacker News Reader

Comment by olliej | Hacker News Reader

I feel they should also be required to provide all details on the people who uploaded them

some sites like Reddit have highly aggressive rules against doxing, where they will hand out permanent subreddit bans, or even site-wide bans. For good reason. People think they are "doing justice", but all they are doing is vigilante justice. No different than the pillory of long ago.

Stop it.

In terms of criminal punishments, is a pillory so bad?

a 10 second internet search would say yes, it is so bad:

> They were liable to be pelted by the crowd with rotten eggs and fruit, dead cats and dogs, mud and every variety of filth, and in extreme cases with stones, saucepans and other missiles that caused serious injury. Some were killed or maimed for life.

https://historytoday.com/archive/daniel-defoe-put-pillory

Okay, so the part that was bad was completely different from the part you get in a doxxing?

reddit admins have banned popular users for posting public WHOIS information. it's ridiculous.

I agree, its ridiculous:

https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_of_Sunil_Tripathi#Misiden...

not the same as my example at all. WHOIS information is already out there, mods on the sub are like "yeah we agree it was wrong, go ahead and ban evade we don't care, the admins fucked up"

We did it reddit!

Remember the time Reddit banned everyone who mentioned that Aimee Challenor (ex-politician expelled from multiple political parties for pedo scandals) was working at reddit?

I don't remember that but it wouldn't surprise me

If someone publishes intimate films of some else then why should they expect their own details to be private?

Why should the victim not have access to the information about their abuser? Why not the police?

I did not say anything about doxxing anyone. I said that the information a porn site has about someone abusing someone else should be made available.

Huh, I guess downvoters think that publishing intimate footage of people without consent should not have consequences. We must protect the privacy of abusers.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com