Hacker News Reader

Comment by Fronzie | Hacker News Reader

The last few years ASML's problem was not supply chains, it was a very high demand. Production was ramped up successfully, but not enough to meet that demand. With regards to Peak IC: atoms aren't getting smaller, Feynmans' "Plenty of room at the bottom" might indeed run it's end.

View on HN

If you chronically can’t meet demand for your critical patented technology, should you be forced to license on terms that allow demand to be met?

The issue isn't patent licensing. If it was, we'd see something competitive coming out of China.

Not for something like ASML which is bleeding edge manufacturing tech that only one company in the world has figured out. It’s very very difficult to replicate that research unless you steal it and replicate all of the surrounding work. Stealing is the easy part and I’m sure China has done that and is attempting replication. But there’s a lot more involved to it I think that’s tricky, troubleshooting and solving bugs is harder when you haven’t internalized how things work (you’re basically rediscovering all the things ASML has learned producing and integrating their tech into a finished product).

That's exactly what I mean. Patents requires publishing so that it could be replicated.

Knowing the underlying principles is only a starting point. The hard work is going from that to production.

Sounds simple, costs millions.

A nation state like China is developed enough that it doesn’t care about millions or even billions for something as strategic as this. They’re looking to potentially invade Taiwan to take over TSMC to get their hands on bleeding edge tech which is going to be significant more difficult and expensive.

East Germany tried the same strategy during the Cold war

Companies know this and a) intentionally make the parents vague (also helps with enforcement) and b) keep a huge amount back as trade secrets. That’s why you have industrial espionage.

Patents don't provide enough information to replicate an invention generally. Especially for complex industrial processes.

The principal goes that no, your prices rise which throttles demand until the two meet, then with the extra money you've charged, you build out new production capacity. That's the idea of free market anyway.

That assumes supply chains still exist that can provide all of the necessary components.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com