The death of the Twitter API is long, long overdue. Bad for us consumers? Sure. But these companies are not charities, they exist to make money.
The death of the Twitter API is long, long overdue. Bad for us consumers? Sure. But these companies are not charities, they exist to make money.
From the article: > Twitter already had a $400m paid API business
If this is true, the API would be generating almost 10% of Twitter's revenue. This is a serious business unit for Twitter.
[1] https://twitter.com/TwitterDev/status/1641222782594990080
That's a huge chasm to cross. A moat, if you will.
Anyone who starts out small and grows organically is just going to get choked out, like planting an acorn in a bucket. So why even try?
Maybe that's the intent?
Sometimes I really wonder about this new CEO guy.
https://techcrunch.com/2023/01/24/how-the-recently-shuttered...
Why couldn't they just add ads within the API instead of alienating the community which is responsible for its success?
Aka, name another major social network around today which has been as influenced by third party clients as Twitter has
Because the first thing every 3rd party client will do is ignore the ads and not show them to users.
Are you sure? That would require a centralized review and distribution process for all 3rd party clients, like the App Store for Twitter. It's not outside the realm of possibility, but there's very little incentive for them.
Realistically, how much of the "content" is already ads? Ie corporate announcements, brand building, or political astroturfing, etc. It's almost like twitter is double dipping.
The problem with Twitter was that it had no legitimate monetization for the app itself. It was a zero-interest, investor/vc money fueled growth machine. And even for that purpose, it used that api to great extent to bring a lot of users into the platform and integrate a vast swath of internet to Twitter - from Twitter logins to automatic embeds to entire 3rd party applications that served different subsets of users.
But now that the investors who dumped cash on something that does not have a level of monetization and revenue compared to its over-inflated valuation want something for their money, suddenly growth is not that important anymore and problems ensue.
Even in this particular situation, its a dumb idea to restrict or close down an api. If you do that, another service that doesnt do it will get an ecosystem built around it and it will eventually eat your lunch. A fixed set of people working on a singular app in a company can never produce as much features as an entire ecosystem with its large community can produce through an api. The Open Source movement and its successes follow the same pattern: Centralized, large corporations cannot compete with the development speed and breadth of communities of millions of people, even if those corporations employ tens of thousands of engineers.
They have a hell of a lot to do with each other beyond that too.
(Led the search API team at Twitter and worked on both API platforms)
for sure. and, as we all know, society only exists so that companies can make money. where would we be without bezos, musk, gates, et al.
On your point: In my opinion 3rd party clients expand services, are a new place of innovation and a place accompanying different usage patterns. The trick is not to kill them; the trick is, to make it work. I would have accepted a Tweetbot with ads. But without Tweetbot I mostly stopped visiting Twitter.
WeChat is pretty lit and contains a whole internet, sort of akin to how Facebook Pages might contain the only information or updates about many businesses and municipalities.
Yes, a state agency will censor some things, just like a corporation will censor some things. Yes, they collect your data and share it with third parties including the government, just like a series of corporation do on every other network. You're not Chinese, you're not going to disappear, its rare they experience anything more than a message disappearing too, its the same user experience. I don't find the reality to be different enough to warrant the perception of reality.
I've used a third-party client for years and I don't miss any features. Maybe I don't know what I'm missing but, like, I can read, comment, and post and that's enough for me.
- Instagram (finally opened in the last two years)
- Youtube
Perhaps I'm not getting your point, but... most of the major social platforms in the US are still open, except for Twitter.
Working API → users
Therefor:
Working API → revenue