Comment by regulators | Hacker News Reader

Comment by regulators | Hacker News Reader

Venmo has massive fraud too. I knew drug dealers in 2017 in San Francisco who openly sold marijuana, cocaine and other drugs via Venmo. Tens of thousands in transactions every 2-months.

Hindenburg criticized the ability for a user to get a debit card by mail in any name but that is a form of KYC. It is true many companies including PayPal don’t force you to provide your social security number. But the user can still be tracked.

I have never provided my social security number or face or ID to Venmo, PayPal or Cash App.

And the name I use on all those accounts is not my legal name. I do pay my taxes, I don’t commit crimes and it’s the name I use in real life and on social media.

This is more an attack on privacy rights and easy access to financial services. If fraud happens, law enforcement should prosecute. Don’t punish the lawful consumer.

Hindenburg’s just a more sophisticated scammer who apparently made $5 million off this trade-

https://twitter.com/unusual_whales/status/163897860486766592...

> Hindenburg criticized the ability for a user to get a debit card by mail in any name but that is a form of KYC.

Not sure I understood you correctly, but this is the opposite of KYC.

Did they mean that once you obtained banking in one false name you could use that to pass KYC with other facilities?

I thought maybe it's something like that, but that's still not KYC. Or maybe it's software engineer's "know-your-client" in a way, where if you have a consistent internal ID for the client that's enough. :D

But does anyone really "know" their customer?

I wonder how far you could get, if they provide a bank like statement you might be able to get phone servce / utilities (in parts of the world where your SS number isnt your password). Likely never able to get an actual bank account through however.

I am not too aware how it is in the U.S. In continental Europe you usually need to provide verifiable form of official identification, like a driver's license, a national ID card, a passport, or any of that in digital form (like the Estonian ID program for example). I never got this thing with utility bills.

The point here is to prevent money laundering and KYC is one instrument out of many for this.

Now come to think of it, in Germany for example, if it can be shown that if a bank employee, even after a good KYC had reasons to doubt that the account holder is the ultimate recipient of the funds or if the client is involved in money laundering, they might be personally criminally liable. Wonder how that is in the U.S.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com