Probably when Frank Sinatra was alive but certainly not now.
What can you get in New York that you cannot get somewhere else?
https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-06-07/is-new...
Art/museums... top notch collections
Restaurants... you can find any type of food here
Sports.. I used to go to the US Open tennis every year... then there is football, baseball, MLS soccer.. all of these are within 1 hour
Sit down at a restaurant table on a sidewalk and just people watch
Broadway shows
Concerts
Beaches are close by
Hunter mountain for skiing is not too far
3 airports that have flight going everywhere
Those are just a few........
I wouldn't brag about NYC's beaches and skiing.
I’m not hating on the city, just pointing out that New Yorkers often believe that only NYC has stuff and every other city is a barren wasteland.
Concerts are an excellent way to lose your hearing.
Restaurants are enjoyable but they will drain you economically.
Spectator sports are a great way to get fat while watching someone else doing sports.