Pimoroni introduces Inky Frame with seven-color 4-inch E Ink display

When it's now 10 minutes away (data unchanged) you'll need to spend 30 seconds refreshing the screen to say that and then it'll be 9 minutes away.

So they show the time for 11 minutes instead of spending 30s of every minute refreshing the display.

The problem is the duty cycle, not screen real estate - if you show a relative time, it needs to update frequently to remain accurate.

If it's 5:27 right now and the BART comes at 5:38, I need to update once per minute if I'm showing a "+11m" for that relative time to remain accurate. Since the display takes more than 30s to refresh and isn't readable while it's refreshing, that means it's useless > 50% of the time I try to glance at it.

Whereas with my current setup, I only update it once one of the BART arrival times is no longer in the future. So, right now it's showing arrivals at 6:23, 6:29, and 6:44. Which means the display will update at 6:23, 6:29, and 6:44. There's a little extra optimization added to only show BARTs that are at least 5min in the future, since the BART is a 5min drive from the location where the display is. Depending on the BART schedule, all this works out to roughly ~8min update cycle on average, meaning that the display is only unreadable due to refreshing about 6% of the time, which I find to be very acceptable.

(I couldn't verify this quickly, but it's something I've heard a few times)

E-Ink Carta uses an LCD layer for the color filter, so it has standard E-Ink response times. These things seem to have multiple pigments, which have different weights and are separated from each other by quickly pulsing the display back and forth right, which takes a long time.

For this kind of separation waveforms probably matter a lot more, but hobby applications seem to have been doing fine with custom waveforms. They may not perfectly respond to the current temperature or have optimal ghosting prevention, but they do (from all examples I've seen) produce good images. Getting fast updates seems to be mostly a function of daring to drive the device with high power (which can lead to stuck pigments if overdone, but this can often be corrected with some flashing).

I've worked close with e-ink before in a past life getting early access to prototypes and pre-release tech, and can confirm that yields ware a huge issue back then holding back progress (I remember they had some really cool shit in the lab that I still haven't seen come to market). It's why progress is so slow. Patents are a moat, like any other tech company does to protect it's IP, investments and hard work, but it's not the main moat.

Making color/advanced e-paper displays for prototypes and concepts that only work in a trade show is not difficult, but making that at scale, with good yields to guarantee great image quality at low refresh power, low cost for your customers to stay interested and good margins for you to stay in business is the impossible part.

Very similar to the challenges of scaling down silicon nodes except you're doing it at your own expense, without the dozens of billions that governments and major companies are pouring in it.

Things will stay as is or will progress very slowly, not because e-ink is some evil corporation abusing the patent sistem to hold back progress, but because e-paper displays are used in this product niche of mostly e-readers and digital signage, which have long upgrade cycles and very low margins, meaning there's too little money to make huge leaps, while all the big money in display tech is going into OLED and micro-LED tech as that's what the consumer market wants and buys at large enough quantities and margins, so that's where the big players like Samsung, LG and BOE will be investing in, instead of in e-paper tech.

Tidbyt fits the bill for me. It's more expensive ($179), but it's a super polished product. It has all public transit for the main cities in the US, plus tons of other handy apps (stocks, weather, etc).

https://tidbyt.com/

(No affiliation, other than being a happy customer. There's a promotion this week for $15 off the list price; DM me on twitter if you'd like the referral link)

Inkplate 10.

The last HN article with the Lilygo T-Display (ESP32-based) that showed the news articles was cool, and screwing around with that led to finding an open source weather program for the better T-Display S3. Stupid easy, cheap and fun to throw together or mod.

https://github.com/alexphredorg/lilygo-weather-esphome