Hacker News Reader

Here's some things must be true if consciousness is an illusion:

Qualia does not exist

Subjective experience does not exist

Consciousness does not exist

There's nothing wrong with acting unethically or immoral because nobody actually experiences any harm because nobody experiences anything

Does anyone really think that's true?

View on HN

They (1-3) do not exist but they are psychically real- they are genuine illusions, as instantiated in the dynamic, split-second successive whiffs emerging from the processing of neurons. To think that they (1-3) "exist" in a classical sense is a reification error.

The first three self-constrain impulses to the contrary on morality behaviors.

I guess this comes down to how you define exist and illusion. I don't think I'd agree on your definition of illusion at least.

I'm not sure what you mean that it doesn't exist in a classical sense. That qualia, subjective experience and consciousness are not concrete entities? That something doesn't exist if its an emergent property or that something doesn't exist if its a process?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com