The fine is arbitrarily decided. There isnt anything solid governing the amount if the fine is not % of revenue. So it totally depends on the whim of the regulator. Which is totally in lieu of the principles of civil law that Europe uses. Its more like the common law practice in which the authority can interpret things and can act arbitrarily without solid, inviolable, democratically-made laws governing its behavior.
This may look like working today. Tomorrow you may find it disproportionately hitting whichever segment or sector that the interests behind the incumbent regulatory appointees target.
This is wrong. See GDPR article 83, and https://edpb.europa.eu/system/files/2022-05/edpb_guidelines_...
How is 'evaluation' done and who does the 'evaluating' you think...
There is no solid legal directive defined in GDPR regarding static amounts. They hinge on on the regulators' interpretations.
Anyway, my point was that the fines dispensed nowadays are sensible. As for the future, DPAs know very well that the instant they go rogue, ie. distribute disproportionate fines or misinterpret the law, their decisions will be reversed by an appeal court. It already happened, in fact.
edit: I just read this on the website of my govt:
> The court that sentences the offender is free to set the amount of the fine, but not to exceed the maximum amount set for that offence.
Turns out judges here have even more leeway than my DPA! The finepocalypse should come any day from now. And don't get me started on courts of assizes.
> Anyway, my point was that the fines dispensed nowadays are sensible.
The sensible fines of today do not guarantee the fines of the future. The precedent concept does not apply to civil law. When an authority is given free range interpretation power like this, the next batch of regulators can interpret it in however they want. Which is in itself a violation of civil law principles.
> ie. distribute disproportionate fines or misinterpret the law, their decisions will be reversed by an appeal court
No Open Source contributor will risk getting such a fine, then going through a lengthy court battle to revert it. They will just stop contributing.
Good afternoon.
A speeding ticket has a fixed fine, anything more complex than that has some level of arbitrariness.
This is how things work in pretty much every other country of the world.
And of course fines are appealable, etc