Hacker News Reader

Comment by capableweb | Hacker News Reader

Care to share a binary or some other project that is actually beyond a closed alpha? Otherwise not a lot of point in sharing it as an alternative, it's not available to the public.

Edit: signed up for the waiting list and received "Zed currently only targets macOS" so sounds like they only target ~10% of the actual market. Interesting strategy.

View on HN

The strategy is that native macOS UIs are generally easier to develop than native Windows UIs, so they're trying to iterate on that platform first.

If they're building a native macOS UI, how is it ever possible it'll be worthwhile to port that into native Windows UI or "native" Linux UI? If you wanna go cross-platform, you usually consider that from the start, not once you're 50% done, as you're gonna have to redo a lot of work you could have gotten "for free".

The “engine” itself is likely cross-platform, with vendor-specific UIs.

It’s likely quicker to develop for a single OS and then build the additional UIs with a more feature-complete app.

Arc browser is also doing this, and they're planning on debuting the Windows UI in Fall.

Isn’t the whole selling point behind their thing that they don’t use the native macOS UIs but instead send everything to the GPU?

Rendering a platform native GUI and what you render it on are two different things. In the case of Zed, its a combination of - metal is quite easy to work with - apple has clear design guidelines and nice toolkits

The Xi editor team quickly found out how much of a mess "native" gui's were on windows. Zed will hopefully add support for vulkan and linux/windows later, but it makes sense to start off on macOS

Metal is not a platform native GUI, it is Apple's graphics API. The native UI on the platform is Cocoa (which calls Metal for some things, but isn't being used here).

I've got invites (and am not otherwise affiliated with the project) if you want to test it out. Username @ Gmail works.

If it's still Mac only, I don't have any real use for it, can only use editors that works across Windows, Linux and macOS, otherwise there is no real point in me trying them out :/ But I thank you for the offer, might reach out in the future if I hear it's available on more platforms.

Send one my way - ashishbhatiya18@gmail.com

If you have another invite to spare, I'd be very grateful to accept one! Email is: spidershred01@gmail.com

Reply on news.ycombinator.com