Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by bikamonki | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

bikamonki

Except ChatGPT "is not aware" that it understands.

View on HN

At what point of the machine telling you it is aware do you believe that it is actually aware?

The building blocks are the same - neural nets. The language outputs are the same enough to fool a human.

So what’s that elusive secret sauce that makes you ‘aware’ and other things not?

Sure, it's told me that it is aware. It also has told me that its mother died, that it has traveled the world and visited the pyramids, and that it is lactose intolerant. At what point of the machine telling you those things do you believe it?

I believe that it believes those things are true just as some people believe the earth is flat.

And unlike your other examples how are you going to convince the machine it’s not aware when the only physical difference is a wet neural net versus a dry one?

It’s very easy to convince the machine it isn’t aware. Instead of prompting it with “you are an AI assistant, please tell me what I want to hear”, you prompt it with “you are not aware” and it will happily tell you that it is indeed not aware, and it will vigorously defend that position. Do you not believe it when it says it is not aware?

I believe that is what it believes..

The fact that I am aware given there’s no physical evidence to indicate why I should be implies that everything is aware at some level.

Secret sauce, no clue. Some folks are working on AGI precisely looking for that secret sauce. ChatGPT is just a tool, a very clever one. Just as a chainsaw cannot drill holes, ChatGPT cannot do many, many other intellectual tasks. We have other very clever AI tools. All can fool humans as well. But I imagine the first phones or TVs also fooled humans. Tools, just tools so far. I think even if we ever build an artificial brain and wire it correctly, it will still be just a tool. I think AGI is not a hardware problem but a software one. Given the necessary hardware, can we program AGI?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com