Hacker News Reader

Not really. Microsoft has inserted their own identity system into an OSM application they built. There's no problem if there's a login modal to use your OSM identity to make edits. They can even have a "let Microsoft manage my OSM account" checkbox with the relevant legalese if they want that to be slick.

View on HN

But there's the problem: if you don't have an OSM account, the user needs to go sign up for one. If Microsoft creates the account for them, that's not just legalese, they might still be seen as the data controller. Or, at least it may be problematic enough to give the in-house lawyers a headache.

But that's not a problem at all! That's exactly the desired/required operation. OSM wants a very clear demarcation: this may be a Microsoft application, but you are an OSM community member (if you want to contribute).

That's perfectly encapsulated by a signup/login barrier. Any slick-ness on top of that fundamental requirement is sugar

Reply on news.ycombinator.com