Ask HN: Why did HN get rid of the “web” button? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Why did HN get rid of the “web” button?

8 pointshammock5 comments

We used to have a Web button in the menu buttons of each post that would take you to the archive.is version of a paywalled article. Instead now it’s gone and we have to wait for someone to comment the link (or do it ourselves), and hope that dang pins the comment to the top before we find the article ourselves. It’s a suboptimal solution. What gives?

View on HN

There was never a web button that took you to an archive version of a paywalled article. There was a web button, but it took you to a Google search of the title phrase.

We got rid of it in July 2020. Actually we took out both the 'past' and 'web' links, but people complained a bunch about 'past' so we put it back.

> we have to wait for someone to comment the link (or do it ourselves),

It is not hard to "do it yourself" Start by putting this bit of javascript below into the URL field of a bookmark, give the bookmark a name you like, and put the bookmark somewhere you can find it again:

    javascript:(function(){window.location="https://archive.is/"+window.location;})();

Then, when you hit a paywalled site, push this bookmark you made while the paywall site is up. You'll get back either the "view an archived copy" page from archive.is, or you'll be offered the option of actually archiving the page (after which you can view the archived version).

From submission https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26866482 and comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26867411 by dang:

> Removed in July 2020. I removed 'past' as well but there was more pushback about that so I put it back.

Seems it was removed a long time ago (I didn't really notice), but I cannot find any closer reasons why it was removed. My guess is that it wasn't really used much.

Probably needed to make room for the hide button. I find this button the most annoying aspect of HN.

For iOS people, I've made the following shortcut:

https://www.icloud.com/shortcuts/8389264a41c844eb817981fba4f...

Install it, invoke it from the Share sheet, and it takes you straight to the archive results. (When the shortcut asks for permission to access the web page, tap "Always Allow".)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com