Comment by wwhchung | Hacker News Reader

Comment by wwhchung | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Actually, here are the 100k tax rates for Waterloo, Ontario, Canada vs. SF, California: Waterloo:

26% Federal + 11.16% Provincial = 37.16% http://www.cra-arc.gc.ca/tx/ndvdls/fq/txrts-eng.html

San Francisco: 28% Federal + 9.3%x(0.72) State = 34.7% <-- (9.3%x0.72 because you can deduct your state taxed amount in certain scenarios)

http://www.efile.com/tax-rate/federal-income-tax-rates/ https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/catxrate_exmpt07.shtml

Once you get above 174k/year, it's sill similar, with:

Waterloo: 29% Federal + 11.16% Provincial = 40.16%

San Francisco: 33% Federal + 9.3%x(0.72) State = 39.7%

So at 100k, Canadian taxes are very slightly higher higher, and is almost even at 174k.

If you're working at a startup, Canada may even be more advantageous because of how capital gains taxes are treated on privately held CCPC's. Also, you have health care. :)

Health care is a given in the U.S. if you're making that kind of salary so for me it was always a non-issue.

Try re-calculating the tax rates if you have a non-working spouse (as was my case since I was on a work visa) and you're significantly better off in the U.S.

"If you're working at a startup, Canada may even be more advantageous because of how capital gains taxes are treated on privately held CCPC's"

This is huge. Read as "the first $750K of your startup windfall is tax free".

http://www.irs.gov/publications/p17/ch22.html

Yup, this is true. I updated my posts to reflect this. However once you get above 200k range, AMT starts to kick in and you can't deduct the full amount.

Except that you deduct your state/local income tax from your federal income tax.

Edit: Your statement that you can deduct income tax is True IF you don't take the standard deduction. Basically in your deduction, you can choose to take the standard $5800 deduction, or deduct the total taxes you paid for california (at $100k, it is only marginally over $5800). At over 200k, you are likely to get hit with AMT, so the deduction would be limited.

I've updated the tax rates above to be more indicative of the adjusted rates in the best case scenario, but California vs. Canada is still VERY close.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com