Hacker News Reader

Comment by misnome | Hacker News Reader

But, they are the same, because google treats them as the same?

Are you saying that there is someone registered with exactly the same account name on gmail, except with an added period?

View on HN

yes, I can't speak to the specific algorithm google uses for account lookup, but if an email comes in for firstnamelastname@gmail.com and it doesn't exist but firstname.lastname@gmail.com DOES exist, google will send it to that mailbox.

the "algorithm" in this case is very simple. Periods are stripped entirely.

m.y.n.a.m.e@gmail.com and myname@gmail.com and my.name@gmail.com all canonicalize to the same account.

Yes, but google also prevents someone with registering an account with the same name, and ignores periods when doing that check. But your post implied that they actually had the same email address, with the periods stripped?

So, it seems likely the other person still wrote their email address down wrong - but it wasn’t the periods that they got wrong. If this is the case, then I can’t see how there is anything google could do to fix this situation.

FWIW I have <first initial><surname>@gmail.com and get loads of email intended for <first initial><their middle initial><surname>@gmail.com, apparently they just keep writing it wrong.

The service that sent that receipt was one of those 3rd party services for small vendors. You go to a bakery and they are able to magically email you a receipt, that sort of thing.

So I very much doubt the person put their email in incorrectly, but I understand your point.

The exact mechanics of how it happened I don't know, but I very much disagree with firstname.lastname@gmail.com and firstnamelastname@gmail.com resolving to the same address.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com