Hacker News Reader

Comment by MonkeyMalarky | Hacker News Reader

Banning links to Facebook? Really?

This flying by the seat of the pants moderation style reminds me of friends in highschool running their own phpBB instances and IRC channels..

Also, Telegram, Discord, Tumblr aren't listed? Lol.

View on HN

I had the same thought recently, this reminds me of old-school forums where the single admin would just make ridiculous arbitrary rules based on specific random things that bothered them. “No more posts about doughnuts ever, after what pwnyb0y86 did last week”, “if you post a question that has been asked in the last 24 hours you get a 3 day ban” etc etc.

It's exactly a classic "mod meltdown" situation. Like the guy who brought Freenode (hn passim)

Actually only links to profiles calling for follow. If I understand correctly.

I don't think you're understanding correctly. It doesn't even allow link aggregators such as link tree, on posts or bios.

I didn't talk about those but deep links to Facebook or Instagram posts. If I'm no mistaken those are authorized.

It seems like it's not allowed, otherwise the policy is way too easy to circumvent.

It's not clear to me what will constitute promotion vs cross-linking. I'd avoid any links for now until Twitter's enforcement rules become clear.

Musk refers to it as "free promotion of social media platforms", he's taking it personally. Personally I think they should all respond in kind.

If they list Tumblr might as well list MySpace

Reply on news.ycombinator.com