If one was to lose this argument and be made to pay a fine, could they demand the original parking fee back? Obviously they paid for a service that was not rendered.
Bureaucracy is the formalization and glorification of pettiness; you can't beat it at its own game.
No.
> Obviously they paid for a service that was not rendered.
There was no service paid for here, so what are you talkimg about?
If someone sold an AI-based “parking dispute letter writing service”, then the service would be writing the letter.
I suppose if someone sold a “guaranteed parking ticket elimination service”, AI-based or not, and it didn’t eliminate the ticket, you’d have a refund claim.