Hacker News Reader

Comment by ShakataGaNai | Hacker News Reader

He's not entirely wrong. If we had a good way of getting a warhead to an incoming asteroid, it'd be a great safety mechanism. Unfortunately, today, there is no one trustworthy to put that sort of weaponry into somewhere that would allow it to strike any location on earth with less than a few minutes warning. Especially since something of that yield would devastate a large portion of earth.

Though lets be honest, anything in orbit is dangerous. A crowbar (aka Rods from God aka https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment ) is even smaller and just as dangerous.

View on HN

Imagine you we’re an insane billionaire with the ability to launch objects into say a lunar distance orbit. It wouldn’t require a lot of cold gas to drop some rods onto any spot on earth, and it would be undetectable until the explosion happens.

As space becomes easier to access the risk increases exponentially.

Well, fortunately we don't have any insane billionaires with the ability to launch stuff into orbit... /s

It would require quite a lot of it because you need to significantly change the orbit, especially if you want it to still be plenty fast on impact.

And it doesn't make much sense either. A billionaire can just pay a few millions to send a guy in a car bomb or a cessna full of explosives. It's way simpler and just as undetectable until the explosion happens.

IIRC nuclear weapons aren't very effective against asteroids in a vaccuum. Unless you can place the warhead inside the asteroid somehow.

Simple, just teach deep-core drillers how to be astronauts and send them to implant it.

That would make for a great movie, could be titled like it's the end of the world. Maybe Apocalypse Now?

A powerful nuke could certainly alter an asteroid's trajectory. However, most of the energy would be wasted. It'd be better to use a nuclear propulsion reactor strapped to the side of the asteroid to direct it more accurately, but we don't have that technology today, whereas we do know how to make big bombs.

Also, the idea of changing an asteroid's trajectory just before it hits the Earth is crazy. You need much more warning, because even a big bomb isn't going to move the asteroid that much, so you need to use it long before it's projected to collide.

Nuclear weapons which are optimized for wide surface area destruction or bunker busting are not very effective. Nuclear bombs like any bomb can be tuned to produce a variety of effects. See Nuclear shaped charges https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_shaped_charge

Reply on news.ycombinator.com