Hacker News Reader

Comment by xeromal | Hacker News Reader

It looks like they're blocked from editing wikipedia articles without an account or am I misunderstanding wikipedia's response?

Blocking anonymous editing from a range of IPs to combat malicious editing seems ok in my book since they allow alternative means.

View on HN

That's how I read it as well, which would mean the headline above is very clickbaity.

Yamla: "You can, however, still edit while logged in with an account."

The problem is that all EE users are both blocked from editing and from directly creating an account.

But they link a process to create an account which I assume is to combat automation.

Yes but then you have to wait in a queue for someone to create the account for you. That is, if they don't deny that too. Also they require your email address for this process.

It's just more and more barriers when all you want to do is quickly correct some information in an article you read. Very frustrating and counterproductive!

So if you're on the go, and you're the type of person who wants to edit wikipedia, you'll be prompted to log in. If you don't have an account you would need to create one which probably involves waiting 'til you're back at home or the office. That's ... not that bad, I imagine they didn't do it randomly but because they had a wave of bad-faith edits from EE users.

There are over 26 million EE users. Some of them are going to go to Wikipedia and make malicious edits because some people are just like that. But punishing everyone else for it seems like overkill to me.

I imagine it takes quite a few for Wikipedia to decide to block them outright ...

But they're not blocked from editing — they just need to be logged in. Wikipedia users can use their existing account. New users were given a human-reviewed path for directly creating an account, apparently out of necessity.

Though it sounds like the normal automated account creation flow is also blocked from that ISP. That could be more problematic and discourage editor account creation.

I thought they were blocked from viewing Wikipedia and this article title was created by the HN user.

It's clickbait and the user created his account only 30 mins ago just to post this.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com