Hacker News Reader

The only Greg Bear books I've read are Forge of God and Anvil of Stars.. they were well-written, but the story sucked IMO. It was just so dark, and full of vengeance. A whole universe burning in the fires of vengeful rage, haha.

Are his other books like that too? Or is the tone a little less murderous?

View on HN

So many sci-fi books come across as basically the same, I like Forge of God precisely because it is so dark and uncompromising and is like works like Gateway and Worlds or Ballard’s works that read more as literature than genre sci-fi.

Also from the view point of SETI there is the awful truth that we really shouldn’t be trying to communicate w/ other life because the most practical meaningful form of interstellar communication is bombing with relativistic or sub-relativistic projectiles. See The Killing Star where aliens watched Star Trek: The Original Series and thought we might be dangerous, then saw Star Trek: The Next Generation and realized they could take us.

That's a good point, I can see the appeal of a different perspective.

I think that was my favorite part of the Three Body Problem. The "F You" attitude it has toward optimism, individuality, liberty.. haha

Much of the appeal of Eon is that it describes a fairly believable and coherent post-scarcity/transhuman society.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com