Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by chollida1 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

chollida1

> The strategy they are describing (selling covered calls) is actually less risky than holding the underlying.

Not necessarily. If you assume the idea is to make money, say a stock is at$100 a you sell a $110 call for $2

The stock then goes to $200.

You have lost $90 of gains to make $2.

That's a huge loss.

Selling covered calls decreases your downside slightly but earning the option premium but it completely destroys your upside by taking away any of the upside beyond the call's strike.

that's much riskier than just owning the stock outright as your downside is capped but yoru upside is unlimited.

View on HN

At least get the numbers right. This would be losing $90 to make $12.

Using Abbot Labs as an example, a $2 option for 10% over current price would expire roughly 4 months out. So you could make $6/year, and only risk losing the gains over 10% that occur within each 4 months.

The types of stock I'll do with this are generally those I view as reliable, possibly with a dividend (yes, increasingly rare these days), with little exposure to catastrophic downside. This chunk of my portfolio is about minimizing the catastrophic as dollars 1-100,000 have a lot more utility in retirement than dollars 1,000,000 -> 1,100,000.

The problem with this line of thinking is assumption that the OP would hold the stock until it reaches $200. But he wouldn't. He was ready to sell at $110. He is better off selling covered call + shares @$110, then only selling shares @$110. Another problem is the assumption that everybody can sell on the top (in this case, $200), while it's obvious they can't. And since when is profit of $10 per share == a huge loss?

And the problem with yoru line of thinking is that at the moment you write a call you are stating the time at which you may be selling the stock.

if you didn't write the call you could sell at any time, but you did write the call so you set the time at which you sell.

if the stock goes up alot then you end up losing alot of the upside.

If you think the stock will go up from $100 to $200, don't sell covered call. Nobody forces you to. But if you have sold it, it means you didn't believe stock would go that much up.

If one sells a covered call but is not ready to sell the stock at that price, that's one's problem, not "covered call is a bad strategy" problem.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com