I think the more interesting part of this is why Google has allowed this woman to manipulate the SERP's in order to bash this guy for so long. They usually have an itchy trigger finger when it comes to burying sites like hers for using keyword stuffing and other questionable SEO techniques.

Likewise, I'm surprised Mr. Padrick never contacted Google to have these pages removed either.

Had either Google or Mr. Padrick done their due diligence, I hardly think this case would have gotten as far as it did.