Hacker News Reader

Comment by newaccount74 | Hacker News Reader

The tech for instant tranfers is already there, they just charge ridiculous amounts for it.

Eg. my bank charges 7€ for an instant transfer, slow transfers are free. This proposal would make all transfers free and instant.

View on HN

Free transfers within some countries are usually instant. That needs to change into always instant and then cross border.

The situation is comparable to mobiles in a decade - it's a profit center for banks, the systems are there but they make more money by getting in the way. So the EU need to step in and regulate this market failure.

My bank (Boursorama) does free instant transfers, so it’s definitely viable for banks.

One of my banks in Portugal charges €1,7 flat for any instant transfer also. It's infuriating to know that the tech is there but banks are just being banks.

It's impossible to make anything free. The likely outcome is the costs will be moved around so that its paid indirectly.

Banks already make enough money from interest on loans, they can afford the minor cost of an instant SEPA transfer. The €7 cost that the parent is charged is way too high, I only have to pay €0.5 for the same with my bank, with a cap of €2,000 on the amount of the transfer (above it can only be the slow transfer).

Yes, hopefully that will be the case when everyone uses it due to economies of scale. A few extra euro cents per transaction should only represent a small burden per account holder.

I hope so. I hope it won't be the case where it's enforced that people have the ability to send money instantly but the cost isn't capped.

I already pay a monthly fee for my bank account, and other banks manage to offer instant transfers for free. I really can't imagine that instant transfers cost my bank 7€ per transaction.

They are just trying to make a quick profit.

Just like card payment processing fees, this is a case where banks are overcharging for a service, and the EU will fix the situation.

Depends on the bank. My bank processes regular free bank transfers as instant if supported by the destination bank.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com