Hacker News Reader

User namespaces have resulted in multiple new container breakout CVEs in the last year. Some guides actually recommend disabling user namespaces because they are still somewhat new and perilous.

View on HN

You're talking about creating new user namespaces inside a container, not running a container in a user namespace. Running a container in a user namespace is strictly a security improvement over running it in the host user namespace.

Also, all container runtimes automatically block unshare(CLONE_NEWUSER) with seccomp already (unless they've disabled seccomp, which I'm not sure if Kubernetes still does).

What are the ones in the last year? They provide security benefits as well. I mean, you could say the Linux kernel is also dangerous and the Windows kernel and pretty much anything that has ever had a CVE. You can also limit it to specific users too if that is a major concern.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com