Hacker News Reader

Comment by rufugee | Hacker News Reader

That's an incredibly broad brush you're painting with there. I've used things like jqgrid and datatables for years now with great success.

View on HN

(Author of DataTables here) Thanks! There are some fantastic plug-ins out there, such as qTip, ColorBox, jqGrid, SlickGrid and many many others. Personally I take great pride in trying to maintain useful, up-to-date documentation, a large battery of unit tests and just generally trying to make the software as useful as possible, for the job that it is intended to do.

So there are (hopefully :-) exceptions to the rule!

Another vote for DataTables here, as it's made the current project I'm working on possible.

One question -- why Hungarian notation for all the API bits?

Legacy basically... When I wrote the first version of DataTables the company I was working fir then had strict coding standards that required the use of Hungarian notation, so I was "trained" in at at the time, and I've never wanted to break compatibility with old versions. v2 might see a clean break though (whenever I get the time to do that :-) ).

please don't do that. part of what makes using jquery plugins so horrific is that every new version is a "total rewrite" and/or drastically changes the API.

the API might use hungarian notation, and you might have fallen out of love with it, but so what? it's a pretty decent API and there's no real benefit to users in changing it. they'll all to have to update/rewrite their JS to stay up to date with the library for effectively no reason.

Thanks for the feedback - I really appreciate it. I'm currently in the middle of developing v1.9 of DataTables and backwards compatibility is key for me here. v2 is a good way off, and I'm certainly not committed to removing the hungarian notation (actually I find it quite useful personally). 1.x and the current API have been going since 2007 and is going to be supported for as long as I can see at the moment. If there are any breaking changes in v2, will be supported in parallel.

I know I don't want to update my own code for a new API on every release! Going back to the point of the OP there are certainly cases when writing custom code is beneficial for that reason, and equally (I believe) there are times when a tried and tested library such as DataTables is suitable.

I love DataTables.

Don't bother breaking compatibility with old versions.

You want to know something that is 100x better? This exact comment on your FAQ page. More people will read it, understand you made that decision, and move on.

If someone cares enough they will fork it and change the variable names. But in reality it doesn't matter.

Awesome - thank you. I think I will do exactly that.

I've found if the plugin has enterprise/business implementations, often that is a good indicator of durability.

Most of the jQuery plugins I've implemented involve me doing a proof of concept with the original plugin, then stripping it down or modifying it to meet any unmet performance or

Mixing plugins can be frustrating - it would be nice if some of them got together to do a plugin distro... it's the next logical extension.

I agree. In any case if you're skilled enough to roll your own, you'll be skilled enough to separate the wheat from the chaff.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com