Hacker News Reader

Comment by ehnto | Hacker News Reader

Whenever I see someone with a very limited GitHub presence, what I actually think is "Ah, this person has a job."

I've been in the industry for a while now and I even use github, but my profile is blank, because all my work is for private companies.

View on HN

I worked as a contractor/freelancer for ages, and coming back into fulltime employee work I was appalled that this was actually considered to be relevant to my impact on the job site. Some of our clients used gitlab, which to github looked like a long stretch of zero activity.

I'm sad that we as an industry use such simplistic and error prone metrics. The closer I get to the hiring side of things, the sadder I get.

I develop software for a living, and I do a very different kind of software dev for myself, as a hobby, in my free time. Its a creative outlet of sorts. On my personal github, I have lots of activity, and its disjunct from my job stuff.

Its not really a great idea, in my opinion, to say "you have a hobby, so you probably dont have a job".

I didn't imply that, I don't assume someone with a good profile doesn't have a job.

There's an option to include contribution activity from private repos. See the "Contribution settings" dropdown on your profile page.

This can easily be manipulated - people are literally writing scripts to do regular but random commits to private repos.

I feel like companies don't use Github as much as individuals. I've seen Azure DevOps used a lot, Gitlab right behind that, Bitbucket as a third option, however I've yet to work for company using Github organizations. And I don't blame them tbh, Github for organizations, has less feafures, but costs a ton more than other alternatives. Other thing i've notices is that sometimes, bigger companies have special deals with Microsoft, that for example include some Azure DevOps features for free.

Do the non-programming vice presidents at these companies know that you don't need a 3rd party host to use Git? That literally a networked file share is enough (assuming a decent VPN)?

Oh, what am I saying, they're mid-level management. Of course a bloated paid solution involving a 3rd party vendor wins over simplicity. Otherwise they'd be out of jobs!

Some of the hosts have significant added value. (And you can self-host them.)

I know of at least three huge, multi-national corporations using Github extensively - either via separate, protected orgs and repos directly on github.com, or a separate Github Enterprise instances on their own domains.

The commenter you're replying to can chime in here for an accurate response- but I assume what he's referring to is that a company usually assigns you a fresh, internal GH account. My past three jobs have all done this, which makes it even harder to demonstrate the work I've been doing to employers... Especially when after leaving a company my GH profile is terminated.

I use a different account for work. I don't want all the crazy IT authentication rules to spill over to my personal account.

This is me. I signed up for github in 2010 and have zero activity.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com