Indeed it is nonsense, web scraping (DMCA archive exemption) and DVR's (time shifting) are both well established as legal practices.
https://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/25/business/media/court-upho... -- So RIAA can STFU and get back to trying to figure out how to better exploit the trash-tier "artists" they've been trying to force everyone to listen to through shady deals and control of media channels/spectra that they only control through artificial scarcity provided by the FCC.