We evaluated about 10 or 15 of them and ended up choosing DatoCMS, a small startup with wonderful features and a terrific editing UI and rich plug in system. Their devs were also very responsive. A bunch of small QoL features like built in imgix support and graphql and such sealed the deal for us.
GraphCMS was a close second, with a very strong data model and solid API, but our editors (marketers, not coders) preferred Dato.
There are a lot of good choices out there. The only one we had a bad experience with was the industry leader, Contentful. They were both outrageously expensive (which wasn't the case when they first started) and also didn't really want us as a customer. They wouldn't even seriously meet with us without a NDA.