Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by 4eleven7 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

4eleven7

Apple doesn't believe in enabling illegal piracy, which is 99.9999999% of the usage of torrents.

Twitter, web browsers, and YouTube are fine on the App Store.

View on HN

A developer might want to offload bandwidth hosting costs to p2p.

I've used torrents to download software so that the provider didn't need to pay bandwidth to share their software.

There are completely legal and reasonable reasons torrenting exists. They're excellent at making huge downloads possible with the more efficient bandwidth. Instead of that, we have an ecosystem of "installers" that exist purely to download massive files to install.

There are many things with technically legal purposes that people often choose not to associate with because they find the cons outweigh the pros. This is that.

I wish torrenting for general downloads was more popular. I had unstable internet that would make downloading anything over 100MB impossible.

Slap a torrent together of the same payload and it'd be guaranteed not to stall/error because of the network.

I agree, I wish they were more common, but you don't need torrents to solve any issues with resuming downloads. HTTP supports sufficient functionality to accomplish this: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Range_requ...

    while; wget -c http://...; end

(From memory, may need tweaking.)

Cons of cryptocurrency outweigh the Pros. Yet these apps are on the app store.

Maybe so. Judgement is subjective.

And I'd be happy if they weren't, but people would be more upset over that than torrent clients.

How so?

> enabling illegal piracy

> YouTube

Hmmm.

And browsers. Go watch series has everything.

Because YouTube "is 99.9999999%" piracy? Hmmmm.

Piracy on YouTube isn't 0%, obviously. But it isn't in the same league, or comparable to torrenting.

Rip. Mix. Burn.

.....riiight.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com