I think I may have the opposite problem. I have contrarian tendencies. I have a strong natural desire to argue against group consensus. When I see too many people agreeing about something to the point that they're not really thinking anymore, I have to take the opposite side. I also generally dislike the kinds of people who always jump on the latest social bandwagon and support the current thing. I can't stand people who can't think for themselves and yet are aggressive when it comes to spreading whatever ideas authority figures have managed to implant into their minds.
It makes no sense to me why someone would spend so much energy and invest so much of their ego into an idea which not only they didn't come up with but which they haven't even bothered to analyze from first principles.
It disturbs me that people can be at once so malleable to the will of authority figures and yet so rigid and stubbornly resistant to basic reasoning.