Swastika Mountain in Oregon may have a new name soon | Hacker News Reader

Swastika Mountain in Oregon may have a new name soon

cnn.com

1 pointTomte5 comments

I'm still pissed "Squaw Peak" in Phoenix, AZ was renamed for some Native American woman, even though she was still alive/ had not yet been dead for the amount of time required for such honorific namings.

That mountain will be "Squaw Peak" until the day I die.

Who decided you have to be dead to have something named after you, and what basis did they have for deciding that?

"The Governor's lobbying, while ultimately successful, proved to be controversial. The controversy stemmed in part from the fact that governor's request violated a required waiting period of five years after a person's death prior to renaming a geographic feature; Piestewa had been killed earlier that year while deployed on active military duty in Iraq." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piestewa_Peak#Name

Googling "five years after death geographic feature" gives me a United States Geological Survey Source https://www.usgs.gov/us-board-on-geographic-names/how-do-i

If a monument could be named a day or a month after someone's death, that may create a Perverse Incentive for "early deaths" for brownie points...

  >"I thought 'this is crazy,'" Joy McClain, 81, said when she saw the mountain's name in a local paper and felt called to action.

..because she's so fucking stupid she doesn't know that the swastika [both name and symbol] existed for hundreds, if not thousands, of years before the Nazis commandeered it.

https://reclaimtheswastikasymbol-bl-blog.tumblr.com/

I guess when you get to that age, you have nothing better to do with your time. It doesn't sound like the current name is causing any problems. Doesn't seem like renaming it would either.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com